top of page
Search

What is the pinnacle for new authors?

Writer: Indie Publishing 101
Indie Publishing 101
Oct 30
3 min read

Updated: Nov 1

While attending a conference last week for authors my wife was astonished how many new authors still, first and foremost, want to be contracted with a publisher versus going down the Indie path. Why is this still such a draw?



I did some digging and realized that traditional publishing offers something many prospective authors want alongside readers: The feeling of having been chosen. An agent and a publisher saying “this deserves to be published” can carry more emotional weight than publishing it yourself.


There may are also be practical reasons:

  • They want to write, not run a business. For some, Indie publishing may mean editing, design, production, and marketing which may not be their cup of tea.

  • They want someone else to take the financial risk. A traditional publisher pays production costs, advertisement and may provide an advance.

  • They want access and credibility. Bookstore distribution, certain review outlets, and literary recognition can be harder to pursue independently.

  • Their picture of success is inherited. For many people, “becoming an author” still means an agent, a book deal, and seeing their book in a bookstore.


Many new authors also assume that a publisher will also deliver an audience. A deal with a publisher, however, doesn’t guarantee substantial promotion or sales, and many authors underestimate how much audience building they’ll still have to do themselves.


Case in point. I know a very famous author whose publisher expected her to do all the promotion, advertisement and "buzz creation" on her own dime and her own effort. The only assistance they offered was putting her book on their website and sometimes running pricing promotions. That is not a lot of assistance.


So I am left with the following conclusion: Some authors pursue traditional publishing because it fits their goals; others pursue it because they haven’t separated wanting readers from wanting industry approval.


Indie publishing makes that distinction much harder to avoid.


So what are the odds of writing and publishing a book through a traditional publisher versus indie publishing? As with most things, it depends! Getting a finished book published, indie publishing offers far more certainty. Making a living from it, neither route offers very reliable odds. I’m using “indie” here to mean self-publishing.

Goal

Traditional publishing

Indie publishing

Finish writing a book

Depends on the author

Depends on the author

Make the finished book available for purchase

Requires a publisher to accept it

Largely within your control, subject to platform requirements such as KDP

Find paying readers

Publication doesn’t guarantee sales

Availability doesn’t guarantee sales

Build a profitable career

No dependable universal success rate

No dependable universal success rate

Platforms such as Amazon KDP let authors publish ebooks and print books without a publisher choosing them, although books must meet content and formatting requirements. kdp.amazon.com


For traditional publishing, I wouldn’t trust a blanket claim like “you have a 1% chance.” There isn’t a reliable industry-wide figure tracking unique aspiring authors through to book deals. QueryTracker, for example, collects individual submissions and responses: one author querying 50 agents creates 50 records, not 50 authors. An agent’s acceptance rate therefore isn’t your overall probability of publication. QueryTracker


The financial evidence is sobering. The Authors Guild’s 2023 survey, covering 2022 earnings, found:

  • Across all surveyed published authors, median annual book income was $2,000.

  • Among full-time self-published respondents, median annual book income was $12,800. The Authors Guild


Those are annual author earnings, potentially across multiple books—not first-book earnings or a beginner’s odds of success. The survey also starts with published authors, leaving out people who never got published.


Bottom line: Indie makes publication a decision you can execute. Traditional publishing makes it an outcome someone else must approve. Whether either produces a sustainable business is a separate question but it all goes back to what is your ultimate goal?


For a new author, the pinnacle or ultimate goal might be:


  • Finishing and publishing their first book.

  • Earning a traditional publishing deal.

  • Becoming a bestseller or winning a major literary award.

  • Building loyal readers and making a living from writing.


For many first-time authors, publishing a book that connects with readers is usually the first major milestone.


Let me know your thoughts if you agree or disagree?


Indie or Traditional

  • Indie Publishing is better

  • Traditional is better


 
 
 

Comments


© 2026 IndiePublishing101

  • Black Facebook Icon
  • Black Twitter Icon
  • Black Instagram Icon
bottom of page