Indie Publishing 101

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer—it depends on your goals, genre, and how you like to market.

​

Going Exclusive (e.g., Amazon KDP Select / Kindle Unlimited)

 

Pros:

​

• Access to Kindle Unlimited (KU): You get paid per page read, which can be very lucrative—especially in high-consumption genres like romance, fantasy, and thrillers.

• Better visibility on Amazon: Amazon tends to favor KU books in its algorithms, which can mean more exposure.

• Promotional tools: You can run Kindle Countdown Deals and Free Book Promotions.

• Simpler to manage: You’re only dealing with one platform.

 

Cons:

​

• Platform dependency: You’re tied to Amazon. If rules change or your account has issues, your income is at risk.

• Limited audience: You miss readers who use Apple Books, Kobo, Google Play, libraries, etc.

• No direct pricing control in some cases: KU dynamics can affect how you position your book.

 

Going Wide (publishing on multiple platforms)

 

Pros:

​

• Multiple income streams: You’re not reliant on one retailer.

• Wider reach: You can access international markets, libraries (via OverDrive/Libby), and different reader ecosystems.

• More control over your business: Less risk tied to a single company.

• Stronger long-term brand building: Especially useful if you want a sustainable author career across platforms.

 

Cons:

​

• Harder to gain traction early: You don’t get the KU boost or Amazon algorithm preference.

• More complex: Managing multiple platforms, pricing, and promotions takes more effort.

• Marketing is on you: Wide authors often need to drive more of their own traffic.

 

A practical way to think about it

​

• If your goal is faster growth and income early on, and you write in a KU-friendly genre → exclusive can be a strong starting point.

• If your goal is long-term stability, diversification, and global reach → going wide is often better.

• Many authors do a hybrid approach: start in KU to build momentum, then move wide later.

 

The real question isn’t “Which is better?”—it’s “Which fits your current stage and strategy?”

​

Which fits your current stage and strategy?

​

1. Brand New Author (no audience yet)

 

Best starting move:  Go Exclusive (Amazon/KU)

​

Why:

​

• You need visibility, and Amazon is the easiest place to get it

• KU readers are more willing to try unknown authors

• Simpler setup while you’re still learning

 

Strategy:

​

• Focus on one genre

• Publish consistently (this matters more than perfection)

• Use KU to build early readership and reviews

 

2. New Author but Willing to Market Actively

 

Best move: Either, but lean Exclusive unless you already have traffic

​

If you:

​

• Don’t have an email list

• Aren’t running ads

• Aren’t building a platform yet

Exclusive is still easier

​

If you:

​

• Have a blog, social following, or email list

 

You can consider going wide earlier

​

3. Established Author (some books + reviews)

 

Best move:  Consider Going Wide (or hybrid)

​

Why:

​

• You already have proof your books sell

• You can start building multiple income streams

• You’re less dependent on Amazon algorithms

 

Strategy:

​

• Move older titles wide first

• Keep new releases in KU if they perform well

• Expand into libraries and international markets

 

4. High-Output Genre Writer (romance, fantasy, thriller, etc.)

 

Best move:  Strong case for Exclusive (KU)

​

Why:

​

• KU readers binge series

• Page reads can outperform direct sales

• Amazon dominates these genres

 

5. Niche / Nonfiction / Business / Memoir

 

Best move:  Go Wide

​

Why:

​

• Your readers aren’t KU-dependent

• You benefit from:

  • Apple Books

  • Google Play

  • Libraries

• Discoverability often comes from outside Amazon anyway

 

In Summary, Ask Yourself This?

​

• Do I want fast traction? → Exclusive

• Do I want long-term stability? → Wide

• Do I want less complexity right now? → Exclusive

• Do I want control + diversification? → Wide

​

One honest piece of advice most people won’t tell you

​

Your publishing strategy matters less than consistency and quality early on.  A mediocre book wide vs exclusive won’t change much.  A strong book + consistent releases? That’s what moves the needle.

​

If we ask this same question but make it genre specific such as Cozy Mystery genre, your strategy for going Exclusive or Wide might be:  

​

• If you're just starting out → Go Exclusive (KU)

• If you’re thinking long-term brand + libraries → Plan to go Wide later

 

Why Cozy Mystery Works Well in Kindle Unlimited

 

Cozy readers tend to:

​

• Read a lot (they binge series)

• Prefer familiar characters and settings

• Stick with authors once they like them

 

That behavior fits KU perfectly:

​

• You get paid for page reads across a series

• Readers are more willing to try book 1 for free (to them)

• If they like it → they’ll read book 2, 3, 4…

 

This is where indie cozy authors often make solid income.

​

But here’s the catch (important)

 

Cozy mystery also has a huge library audience:

​

• Many readers use Libby / libraries

• Strong presence on Kobo (especially Canada)

• Apple Books readers tend to like cozy too

 

So going wide has real upside—but usually later, not first.

​

Recommended Strategy for Cozy Authors

​

Phase 1: Build Momentum (Exclusive / KU)

​

• Launch your first 3–5 books in a series

• Stay in KU to:

  • Gain visibility

  • Build read-through (this is everything in cozy)

• Focus on:

  • Strong recurring characters

  • Consistent release schedule

  • Hooks at the end of each book

 

Goal: Build a loyal reader base

​

Phase 2: Expand (Hybrid or Wide)

 

Once you have:

​

• Multiple books

• Consistent income

• Reader demand

 

Then:

​

• Move older series wide or

• Keep new books in KU, shift backlist wide

 

This lets you:

​

• Tap into libraries

• Reach international readers

• Reduce Amazon dependency

 

Big Mistake to Avoid in Cozy

 

Trying to go wide too early without a series

​

Cozy readers don’t usually:

​

• Buy one standalone and leave

 

They:

​

• Commit to a series

 

So if you only have 1 book:

​

• Wide = slow

• KU = easier discovery

 

One thing that matters more than wide vs exclusive

 

In cozy mystery, your series concept matters more than platform.

​

Things like:

​

• A strong hook (e.g., baker + murder, librarian + small town secrets)

• A charming setting

• A likable amateur sleuth

 

That’s what drives sales and read-through.